The Lawful and the Unlawful
Volume 2: Customs
This document presents an in-depth analysis of the concepts of "the lawful (halāl) and the unlawful (harām)" in Islamic law and ethics. The source text emphasizes that seeking lawful sustenance is not merely an economic activity, but the foundation of worship and a prerequisite for spiritual development. The document details the virtue of the lawful, the spiritual damage wrought by the unlawful, the paths to be followed in doubtful cases, and the four different degrees of taqwā. The central argument is that lawful food illuminates the heart, while the unlawful blocks the acceptance of prayers and renders deeds void.
Summary
This document presents an in-depth analysis of the concepts of "the lawful (halāl) and the unlawful (harām)" in Islamic law and ethics.
Sections
1. The Obligation of Seeking Lawful Sustenance and Its Relation to Spirituality
Seeking the lawful is a duty made obligatory upon every Muslim. The text divides worship into ten parts and states that nine of them lie in "seeking lawful sustenance."
- Fundamental Analogy: Lawful eating is likened to the foundation of the edifice of religion. If the foundation is sound (lawful), the building (acts of worship) rises; if the foundation is rotten (unlawful), the building collapses.
- Spiritual Effect: The heart of one who eats lawful sustenance for forty days is illuminated, and fountains of wisdom flow from his tongue. Conversely, neither the obligatory nor the supererogatory worship of one in whose stomach there is the unlawful is accepted.
2. The Four Degrees of *Taqwā* (*Waraʿ*)
The document creates a hierarchy by dividing levels of avoidance of the unlawful into four main categories:
| Degree | Name | Definition and Scope | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | I. Degree | The Taqwā of the Just | Avoiding what is definitively unlawful in law, whose commission causes a person to be counted as fāsiq and to lose the quality of justice. | | II. Degree | The Taqwā of the Righteous | Staying away from situations that may be unlawful, that outwardly permit concession but appear doubtful. | | III. Degree | The Taqwā of the God-fearing | Abandoning lawful things that outwardly contain no harm, out of fear that they may lead to the unlawful later. | | IV. Degree | The Taqwā of the Truthful | Avoiding every permitted act done for a purpose other than God's pleasure, or merely to satisfy the self, even when it contains no suspicion of unlawfulness. |
3. The Sources and Classification of the Unlawful
Unlawful things are examined in two main groups:
- Dhātī Unlawful Things: Those unlawful in their very essence (wine, pork, foods mixed with impurity, etc.).
- ʿAriḍī Unlawful Things: Those unlawful because of a defect in the manner of acquisition (goods obtained through oppression, usury, theft, defective contracts, or seizure without consent).
4. Doubtful Matters and the Problem of Mixing (*Ikhtilāṭ*)
Starting from the ḥadīth "The lawful is clear and the unlawful is clear; between them are doubtful matters," the text analyzes situations of uncertainty.
- The Principle of Minority and Majority: The existence of unlawful things in the world does not require halting all trade. If unlawful things are not "too numerous and widespread to count," the default is lawfulness.
- Distinction Between Obsession and Taqwā: Avoiding something with no evidence by saying "perhaps it is unlawful" is called "obsession," while avoiding doubtful things based on a reasonable indication is regarded as taqwā.
---
Key concepts
- Spiritual Illumination
- Whoever eats only lawful sustenance for forty days, God illuminates his heart and causes fountains of wisdom to flow from his tongue.
- Worship and Supplication
- Lawful food is a prerequisite for the acceptance of prayers. The supplication and worship (obligatory and supererogatory) of a body nourished by the unlawful risk non-acceptance.
- Struggle Against Satan
- Satan circulates in the veins of the human being like blood. Lawful sustenance restrains desire, narrows Satan's field of action, and defeats his army.
- Jihad and Martyrdom
- One who strives to earn the sustenance of his dependents from what is lawful is ranked with those who strive in God's path or with martyrs.
- Fuel for the Fire
- For flesh composed of the unlawful, the fire of Hell is the foremost recompense.
- Rejection of Acts of Worship
- It is reported that prayer performed in a garment worth ten dirhams in which even one dirham from the unlawful is found will not be accepted.
- Spiritual Blindness
- Consuming doubtful and unlawful things darkens the heart and prevents one from witnessing spiritual realms.
- Farḍ al-ʿayn
- A binding obligation that every Muslim must personally fulfill (such as seeking lawful sustenance).
- Ribā
- Usury; excess obtained through unjust gain and oppression.
- The Truthful (*Ṣiddīqūn*)
- Those who have reached the highest level in *taqwā*, truthful in word and deed, who seek God's pleasure in every affair.
- Waraʿ
- Extreme scrupulousness shown in avoiding doubtful things.
- Tajassus
- Investigating people's hidden states and faults (according to the text, unlawful).
- Imnāʾ
- The hunted animal's disappearing from sight for a time after being wounded, then dying.
- *Ṣarf* and *ʿAdl*
- Terms denoting supererogatory and obligatory acts of worship.
- Permitted (*Mubāḥ*)
- Actions left free, in which there is no religious objection to doing or leaving them.
- *Fāsiq*
- One who does not obey the commands of religion and has made sin a habit.
Study questions
According to the text, in which act are nine of the ten parts of worship hidden?
In seeking lawful sustenance.
To what is the stomach likened, and upon what does the health of this reservoir depend?
The stomach is the body's reservoir; its health depends on lawful eating, its illness on unlawful eating.
According to Ibrāhīm b. Adham, upon what does true understanding (*idrāk*) depend?
Upon knowing what one sends into one's stomach.
What did Abū Bakr do when he learned that the milk his slave brought had been earned through divination?
He put his fingers in his mouth and vomited nearly to death, cleansing his stomach.
What is the ruling on charity made from unlawful sustenance?
The charity is not accepted; rather that wealth becomes fuel that drives the person to Hell.
What is the fundamental criterion in the fourth degree of *taqwā*, "The *Taqwā* of the Truthful"?
That the act or food be undertaken only for God's pleasure and to gain strength for servitude to Him; one avoids everything in which another intention is mixed.